Article Summary

In the UK, there are two main pension schemes: Defined Benefit (DB) and Defined Contribution (DC) schemes. DB schemes have traditionally been the most common type of pension scheme in the UK, but the trend has been shifting in favor of DC schemes in recent years. The shift has been propelled by a variety of factors, including changes in the economy, the law, and the attitudes of both employers and employees.

DB schemes, also known as final salary schemes, offer a guaranteed retirement income based on an employee’s length of service and the salary they receive upon retirement. The employer is responsible for funding the scheme and managing investment risk, and the amount of pension paid is not dependent on investment returns but on the number of years worked and the final salary earned.

In contrast, DC schemes, also known as money purchase schemes, do not offer a guaranteed income in retirement. Instead, the employee and employer contributions to a pension pot are invested in the stock market. The amount of pension paid upon retirement depends on the size of the pension pot and the investment returns earned. The employee bears the risk and must manage their investments and take responsibility for the size of their pension pot.

To learn more about this discussion, you can also watch one of our YouTube videos where we discuss the matter.

What Is A Defined Benefit Pension Plan? What Advice Do You Need? DB Transfer Specialist Explained

The Current State of Defined Benefit (DB) Pensions

DB pensions are a type of workplace pension scheme where an employee’s pension is based on their salary and the number of years worked for their employer. The employer is responsible for contributing to the pension fund and ensuring that there is enough money in the fund to pay out the promised pension benefits.

DB pensions in the UK are complex, with several factors contributing to ongoing challenges. One key factor is the longevity of retirees, which has increased costs for pension providers as they must provide pension benefits for longer periods. Additionally, low-interest rates have made it difficult for pension providers to earn enough money on their investments to meet their obligations.

Another factor is the changing nature of the UK workforce, with more people working in non-traditional, part-time, or freelance roles. This means that fewer people are contributing to DB pension schemes, and those who are may need to work for their employer longer to qualify for a full pension.

The COVID-19 pandemic has also had an impact on DB pensions in the UK, with many employers struggling financially and being forced to cut costs. Some have considered reducing or even closing their DB pension schemes in order to save money, which has led to concerns among employees about the security of their retirement savings.

The Current State of Defined Contribution (DC) Schemes

The shift toward DC schemes has been driven by several factors, including the high cost of providing DB schemes. DB schemes are expensive for employers to fund, and the investment risk is often difficult to manage. Additionally, changes in life expectancy mean that DB schemes are becoming more expensive to provide as people are living longer and the cost of providing a pension for a longer period of time increases.

Another factor is the changing attitudes of employees toward pensions. Many younger workers prefer the flexibility and control offered by DC schemes, as they can choose how their money is invested and take it with them when they change jobs. DC schemes are also seen as more transparent, as employees can see how much money is being contributed and how it is being invested.

Despite the shift towards DC schemes, many DB schemes are still in operation in the UK, particularly among larger companies and public-sector employers who can afford to fund them. However, there is concern that many DB schemes are underfunded and may not be able to meet their obligations to pensioners in the future.

The shift towards DC schemes is likely to continue in the UK as employers seek to reduce costs and employees demand more flexibility and control over their pensions. However, it is important to ensure that pensioners are adequately protected and those in DB plans are not left without the pensions they promised.

Reasons for Transferring DB Pensions

While DB pensions have been a popular retirement income option for many years, there is a growing trend of people transferring out of their DB pension schemes in the UK. Some of the key reasons are discussed below.


Individuals can gain greater flexibility and control over their retirement income by transferring to a DC scheme. They can choose how much to withdraw each year and when to do so, rather than being locked into a fixed income stream for life.

Higher Lump Sum: Transferring out of a DB pension can also enable individuals to take a higher lump sum at retirement. With a DC scheme, they can typically take up to 25% of their pension pot tax-free, while a DB scheme usually offers a smaller lump sum.


Another benefit of transferring out of a DB scheme is the ability to pass on the pension to loved ones. With a DC scheme, any remaining funds can be left to heirs tax-free in most cases, while a DB scheme typically ends when the recipient dies.

Concerns over Pension Scheme Viability

Individuals may also choose to transfer out of a DB pension if they have concerns about the scheme’s viability. If the funding level falls below a certain threshold, the pension may be at risk, and transferring out may provide greater security.

Access to Investment Options

By transferring to a DC scheme, individuals can access a wider range of investment options than with a DB scheme. This can potentially lead to higher returns on pension savings.

Advantages of a DC Pension

A DC pension, also known as a defined contribution pension, is a pension scheme where the retirement income is based on the amount of money paid into the scheme by both the employer and the employee and the investment returns earned. This is different from a defined benefit pension, where the retirement income is based on the employee’s salary and length of service with the employer.

In recent years, DC pensions have become increasingly popular in the UK, with many employers offering them as their default pension scheme. Some advantages of DC pensions include some of the following.


The introduction of auto-enrolment has played a significant role in the growth of DC pensions in the UK. This government initiative requires employers to automatically enroll eligible workers into a workplace pension scheme and make contributions to it on their behalf.

Investment Options

With a DC pension, individuals can typically choose between a default fund or a self-select fund when it comes to investing their money. The default fund is a one-size-fits-all investment solution that aims to achieve a reasonable level of growth over the long term, while self-select funds allow pension savers to choose their own investments.

Fees and Charges

Fees and charges can vary widely depending on the provider and the type of investment chosen. It is important to compare the charges of different investment options to ensure the best value for money.

Retirement Income Options

When it comes to taking retirement income from a DC pension, there are several options available, including an annuity, drawdown, or lump sum.

Is Transferring a DB Pension to a DC Pension Right for You?

While DC pensions may offer greater flexibility and control over retirement income, transferring out of a DB pension scheme is not always the best option. DB pensions provide a guaranteed income for life, which can be a valuable source of financial security in retirement. Additionally, transferring out of a DB scheme comes with risks, such as the possibility of running out of money if you withdraw too much too soon.

The Role of an IFA

If you are considering transferring out of your DB pension scheme, it is important to seek professional financial advice to ensure that you make the right decision for your individual circumstances. A financial advisor can help you understand the potential benefits and drawbacks of transferring your pension and help you evaluate your retirement goals and financial situation.

At Cameron James, we specialize in pension transfers for expatriates from all over the world. Our team of expert financial planners is fully qualified and knowledgeable in the area of transferring pensions to an international SIPP, especially for US residents. We provide clear, regulated, and transparent advice to all of our clients with no hidden fees.

We understand that every client has unique circumstances and financial goals, and we take the time to listen and understand your needs before providing tailored advice. We are dedicated to providing you with the best possible advice and support to help you achieve your retirement goals and financial security.

Take the first step towards a secure financial future by booking a free initial consultation with one of our expert financial advisors today. We can help you understand the pros and cons of transferring your pension and guide you on the best course of action for your circumstances. Contact us today to schedule your consultation.

Our Founder & CEO -
Dominic James Murray

I have been in the UK Pension Transfer industry for over 11 years, and have witnessed seismic changes in the UK Pension rules over the course of that decade. Most to the benefit of the UK Chancellor or to Chequer!

My 5 years as CEO of Cameron James, have certainly been the most rewarding. My goal, has been a simple one. Provide clients with transparent financial advice on a low-cost basis, for them to make informed decisions to protect their families best interests.

Our Clients Love Working With Us!

We have worked hard for our reputation and we will be maintaining it.

5.0 Star Rating